The Evidence for Messiah’s Resurrection
15: 1-11
The evidence for Messiah’s resurrection DIG: Why does Paul remind them of the gospel? What were the first things Paul passed on to the Corinthians? What are the three main points of the gospel? What were the five pieces of evidence? Why the emphasis on the testimony of eyewitnesses? Why the emphasis on God’s grace? Why was Paul a special eyewitness?
REFLECT: What hope does knowledge of your future resurrection to eternal life give you? How can this resurrection hope enable you to withstand evil and pain in your life? What would be the consequences if we were not raised from the dead? What evidence does Paul use to prove that Yeshua Messiah really did rise from the dead? Who can you tell about it?
Messiah died for our sins, in accordance with what the TaNaKh says;
He was buried, and He was raised on the third day.
Before we get into this chapter, it would be good to define the meaning of the resurrection. The resurrection is not spiritual, but physical. The Greek word is anastasis nekron, which means the standing up of a corpse. These bodies of ours are to be raised; the resurrection in Scripture always refers to the body. Thus, it cannot refer to spiritual resurrection. In Paul’s day, in Corinth and in the Roman world, there were three philosophies concerning death and life after death. There was Stoicism, which taught that the soul merged into deity at death. There was, therefore, a destruction of the personality. Such a concept makes the resurrection a nonentity. Then there was Epicurean philosophy, which was materialistic. It taught that there was no existence beyond death. So, there would be nothing to resurrect. The third was Platonism, which taught the immorality of the soul, believing in a process like transmigration. You still find that teaching in Platonism today in the religions of India and the cults in America. It denies bodily resurrection. Because of these philosophies, when Paul mentioned the resurrection while he was in Athens (see the commentary on Acts, to see link click Cb – An Unknown God in Athens – 17:16-34), the Athenians mocked him.477 Immortality of the soul, yes; but resurrection of the body, no! The Sadducees also denied the resurrection of the body (Matthew 22:23; Acts 23;8) and this view is still widely held today. We need to understand very clearly that Paul is not talking about a spiritual resurrection. The soul does not die. The second a body dies; the person goes somewhere else. If that person is a child of God, to be absent from the body is to be present with the Lord (2 Cor 5:6-8). However, if a person is not a child of God, then he goes to a place of torment.478
The doctrinal problem on which this chapter focuses was not the Corinthians’ disbelief in Messiah’s resurrection, but confusion about their own. Paul was not trying to convince them that Yeshua rose from the dead, but that one day they, too, would be raised to eternal life with Him. Nevertheless, to lay the foundation, in the first eleven verses he reviews the evidence for Yeshua’s resurrection, a truth he acknowledges they already believe. Paul gives five evidences, or testimonies.479 His death and resirrection was a fact that could be corroborated by people who were still living at the time First Corinthians was written.
The testimony of the Church: The first testimony is not stated explicitly, but is implied. The very fact that the Corinthian believers, and all other believers everywhere, had received the gospel, believed in Yeshua Messiah, and had been miraculously changed, was in itself a testimony to the power of the Gospel, which is the power of the resurrection of Messiah. The apostle told them that what he was about to say was nothing new to them. Now, brothers, I must remind you of the Good News which I proclaimed to you, and which you received, and on which you have taken your stand and by which you were saved (15:1-2a). The first verse is masterly in every respect. It fits the situation exactly. Paul does not begin by naming the subject which he intends to cover and by stating why he intends to do so. He immediately places the question of resurrection in the context of the gospel, because belief in the Resurrection is an indispensable component of it, not a side issue. Only after reminding the Corinthians how important resurrection is, can he address the difficulty which prevented some of them from believing in it, namely, their inability to imagine how it could happen.480
Paul’s qualifying statement: Provided you keep holding fast to the message I proclaimed to you. For if you don’t, your trust will have been in vain (15:2), does not teach that true believers are in danger of losing their salvation, but it is a warning against non-saving faith (see the commentary on Hebrews Al – How Shall We Escape If We Ignore So Great a Salvation). So, a clearer rendering would be . . . “if you hold fast to what I preached to you, or if you have not crossed the line from mere knowledge to faith, your outward appearance of faith will have been in vain.” John said: They went out from us, but they did not really belong to us. For if they had belonged to us, they would have remained with us; but their going showed that none of them belonged to us (First John 2:19). Therefore, it must be recognized that some of the Corinthians lacked this true saving faith (15:34) and, as a result, did not continue to obey the Word of God.481
Dear Heavenly Father, Praise You for Your abundantly gracious offer of Your righteousness to all who love and follow You! He made the One who knew no sin to become a sin offering on our behalf, so that in Him we might become the righteousness of God (Second Corinthians 5:21). Earth’s pains will be gone and the wonderful peace and joy of life in heaven will be for all eternity. For I consider the sufferings of this present time not worthy to be compared with the coming glory to be revealed to us (Romans 8:18). All who are wise love You with all their heart for You are such a wonderful Father to Your children on earth and You have planned wonderful joys for them in heaven. Things no eye has seen and no ear has heard, that have not entered the heart of mankind – these things God has prepared for those who love Him (First Ccorinthians 2:9).
Praise Your wisdom that is able to see into each person’s heart to discern if they have real saving faith or if it is just an outward appearance of following you. Many will say to Me on that day, “Lord, Lord, didn’t we prophesy in Your name, and drive out demons in Your name, and perform many miracles in Your name?” Then I will declare to them, “I never knew you. Get away from Me, you workers of lawlessness” (Matthew 7:22-23)! It is a joy to love and obey You. In Your holy Son’s name and power of His resurrection. Amen
The testimony of Scripture: In verses 3 and 4 you will see the three essentials of the gospel: (1) we are sinners, (2) Messiah died to save us from our sins, and (3) using the perfect tense (a past completed action with continuing results into the future) Yeshua was raised from the dead and is alive today. So simple that a young child can understand it, and yet so profound that for more than two thousand years the best theological minds the world has ever produced have yet to get to the bottom of these three truths. For among the first things I passed on to you was what I also received, namely this:
1. We are sinners. A person cannot be saved unless he understands what he is being saved from. The Bible declares: For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God (Romans 3:23 NIV). ADONAI is holy and every one of us has fallen far short of His holiness. Isaiah said it this way: We all, like sheep, have gone astray, each of us has turned to his own way (Isaiah 53:6a NIV). Consequently, our penalty for our sins is spiritual death, our eternal separation from God.
2. The Messiah died to save us from our sins, in accordance with what the TaNaKh says. He died. That is a historical fact. Very few would deny that. This confirms His death. Back to the Isaiah passage: And ADONAI has laid upon Him the iniquity of us all (Isaiah 53:6b). Paul put it this way: God made this sinless man be a sin offering on our behalf, so that in union with Him we might fully share in God’s righteousness (Second Corinthians 5:21). The holiness of YHVH demands that we live a morally perfect life. The justice of Ha’Shem demands that when we don’t, we must pay a penalty for our sins. The love of the LORD provided that payment: He sent His one-and-only Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish but have eternal life (John 3:16). As Yeshua hung on the cross, ALL of our sins – past, present, and future – were placed on Messiah. And because of His sin offering, our Lord satisfies every claim of God’s holiness and justice so that He is free to act on behalf of sinners.
3. He was buried. This needs to be added. Why is that important? It proves He didn’t just disappear. It means that they literally had His body. And he was raised on the third day (see the commentary on Jonah As – The Sign of Jonah). The resurrection is part of the gospel. The tomb was empty. A dead Savior is no use to anyone. But Yeshua is not a dead Savior. He is our living Savior, standing at the right hand of God (Acts 2:33). In accordance with what the TaNaKh says in all three of its major sections – The Torah (Leviticus 23:9-15), the Prophets (Isaiah 53:10-12a) and the Writings (Psalm 16:9-11, as quoted in Acts 2:25-32); all are to be understood as referring to Messiah’s resurrection (15:3-4). But is the general resurrection taught in the TaNaKh? Yes, certainly in Isaiah 26:14, “Your dead will live, [God’s] dead body will rise,” and even more unmistakably in Dani’el 12:2, “And many of those who sleep in the dust of the earth will awake, some to everlasting life,” which corresponds to Isaiah 26:14, “and some to shame and everlasting contempt.” This double resurrection is the same as that taught by Yeshua: Those who have done good (Greek: agathos, meaning intrinsically good, as to believers it describes what originates from God and is empowered by Him in their life) to a resurrection of life, and those who have done evil to a resurrection of judgment (John 5:29).482
Which resurrection do you think you are headed for? If I asked you if you were a sinner, what would you say? Romans 3:23 says: For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God. That includes you and me, doesn’t it? Most people feel that being good gets you into heaven and being bad keeps you out. That simply is not true; we all have sinned. What would you say sin is? I think we can agree that we are both sinners; now let’s define sin. Some have said, “I’m not perfect,” or “I have made some mistakes.” But what do you think the Bible means by sin? Well, the Bible says that everyone practicing sin breaks God’s law – indeed, sin is lawlessness (1 John 3:4). Have you ever disobeyed your parents? Have you ever misused the name of God? Have you ever told a lie? This is what sin is. It’s breaking God’s law. And any time you break a law there is a penalty. If you run a stop sign, the penalty is a fine. If you rob a bank, the penalty is jail. What is the penalty for breaking God’s law?
The Bible teaches us that the wages of sin is death (Romans 6:23a). The wages of work is money, but the wages of sin is death. In other words, what I earn – the penalty, the punishment of sin – is death. Death is separation. The Bible speaks of two kinds of death that is two kinds of separation. The first death is separation of the body and the soul. If I were to die right now my body would fall to the floor, but my soul, the real me, would go somewhere else. But the Bible speaks of another death, one it calls the second death. This is separation of the soul from God. Now, the penalty of sin is death, spiritual death, and separation from the LORD. To put it simply – hell. All this is really bad news. But there is good news.
But God demonstrates His own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us (Romans 5:8). We were spiritually dead and unable to make the first move toward God because we inherited Adam’s sin nature that rebelled and separated us from Him. So, God made the first move toward us by sending His one and only Son to die in our place for the payment for our sins. We stand before the Son of God, guilty of sin, and facing a death penalty. But Yeshua, as judge (Jn 5:27), comes down from behind the seat of judgment, takes off His judicial robe and stands beside us. It is there that He says to us, “I will take your place. I will die for you.” And if you were the only person in the world, He still would have died for you. The penalty for sin is death, but Messiah died and paid for sin so we do not have to go to hell.
It is not what you do for God that saves you, it is what God has already done for you.
You don’t get to heaven by what you do; you get to heaven by what you believe.
What is it that I need to believe in, to trust in, to have faith in, to be saved?
For God so loved the world that He gave His one and only Son who died for our sins according to the Scriptures, that He was buried, that He was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures, and whoever believes in Him shall not perish but have eternal life (John 3:16 and First Corinthians 15:3b-4). If you believe this, you are saved.
Nothing else matters.
Salvation = faith + nothing (not baptism, not good works, nothing means nothing). Without faith it is impossible to please God because anyone who comes to Him must believe that He exists and that He rewards those who earnestly seek Him. Now is the day of salvation (Hebrews 11:6 and Second Corinthians 6:2c).
Would you like to be saved right now?
Pray this simple prayer in faith. But before you do, I want you to remember that saying a prayer does not save you, trusting in Yeshua Messiah does. God, I admit that I have sinned. I believe Yeshua Messiah died for my sins and I want to trust Him to save me right now. Lord, please come into my heart and make me a new person. I accept your gift of salvation.
If you were to die right now, where would you go?
Why should God let you into His heaven?
That’s right, because Yeshua died to pay for your sins.483
If you prayed that prayer in faith see my commentary on The Life of Christ Bw – What God Does for Us at the Moment of Faith.
The testimony of eyewitnesses: It is significant that Paul says that Yeshua appeared to those who saw Him after the Resurrection. Until He revealed His identity to them, not even Mary Magdalene (John 20:14-16), the two disciples on the Emmaus road (Lk 24:15 and 31), or the disciples gathered together on Easter evening (John 20:19-20) recognized Him. The gospel accounts consistently speak of Messiah’s appearing after His resurrection (Mt 28:9; Mark 16:9, 12, 14; Lk 24:31-39; Jn 21:1). He was recognized only by those to whom He chose to reveal Himself, and there is no record that He revealed Himself to anyone else.
One of the requirements for apostleship was having seen the resurrected Messiah (Acts 1:22), and the first apostle to whom He appeared was Kefa, that is, Peter (Luke 24:34). We are not told the exact time or occasion for that appearance. We only know that it was sometime after His appearance to Mary Magdalene and before His appearance to the two disciples on the road to Emmaus. We are not told why the Lord appeared to Peter first, but it possibly was because of Peter’s great remorse over having denied his Lord, and because of his role as a leader among the apostles and the early Messianic Community until the Counsel of Jerusalem Act 15.
Messiah next appeared to the Twelve (15:5) as they were fearfully assembled (see the commentary on The Life of Christ Mj – Jesus Appeared to His Apostles). The apostles laid the foundation of the Church (Ephesians 2:20), which from the beginning based its beliefs and practices on their teaching (Acts 2:42). Those men whom the Lord used to establish His Church on earth all saw Him in His resurrected body (Acts 1:22). They were capable, honest, and reliable witnesses to the most important event in history (see the commentary on The Life of Christ Mi – It Is True! The Lord Has Risen).
And afterwards he was seen by more than five hundred brothers at one time. The quality of specific witnesses is represented by the apostles, all of whom were known by name and could easily be questioned. The quantity of witnesses is seen in the five hundred brothers who saw the risen Messiah at one time. Scripture gives no indication who those people were, or where Yeshua appeared to them, but they were surely well known in the early Messianic Community, and, like the Twelve, would often have been questioned about seeing the risen Savior. Even at the time of Paul’s writing, more than two decades later, the majority of them were still alive, though some had died (15:6).
Later he was seen by James, the half-brother of Yeshua, then by all the emissaries (15:7). He was originally a skeptic. Like his brothers, he did not at first believe that Yeshua was the Messiah (John 7:5). But now this member of Yeshua’s own household, this one who for several years did not recognize Him as the Messiah, was a witness, a powerful and convincing witness, to His resurrection. Perhaps, as with Paul, it was the experience of actually seeing the resurrected Messiah that finally brought James to saving faith. In any case, the convincing testimony of a family member and former unbeliever was added to that of the apostles and the five hundred.484
The testimony of a special witness: One of the greatest witnesses of The resurrection was Paul himself, for as an unbeliever, he was thoroughly convinced that Yeshua was dead. In his letters Paul wrote, there are fifty-three references to the resurrection of Yeshua. The radical change in his life – a change that brought him persecution and suffering – is certainly evidence that the Lord had indeed been raised from the dead. And last of all he was seen by me, even though I was born at the wrong time to be one of the original apostles. For I am the least of all the emissaries, unfit to be called an emissary, because I persecuted the Messianic Community of God. But by God’s grace I am what I am, and his grace towards me was not in vain; on the contrary, I have worked harder than all of them, although it was not I but the grace of God with me (15:8-10).
At this point, Paul’s readers would say, “Yes, we agree that Yeshua was raised from the dead.” Then Paul would reply, “If you believe that, then you must believe in the resurrection of all the dead!” Messiah came as a man, one-hundred percent human, and experienced all that we experience, except that He never sinned. If there is no resurrection, then Messiah was not raised. If He was not raised, then there is no gospel to preach. If there is no gospel to be preached, then what you and I have believed is useless and we are still awash in our sins (15:17). If there is no resurrection, then believers who have died have no hope. The conclusion is obvious: Why be a believer if we have only suffering in this life and no future glory in the next? The resurrection is not just important; it is everything, because all that we have now or will ever have hinges on it.485
The testimony of the common message: The last testimony to Messiah’s resurrection was that of the common message that every true apostle, prophet, and pastor preached. Anyhow, whether it was I or they – Peter, the Twelve, the five hundred, James, or anyone else – this is what we proclaim, and this is what you believed (15:11). Without question, the preaching and teaching in the early Messianic Community centered on the death, burial, and resurrection of Messiah. It was the pivotal message that was proclaimed. There was no dispute about the truth or the importance of the doctrine, which hardly would have been the case had it been a lie. Except for a few isolated heresies, the doctrine of Messiah’s resurrection has not been questioned within the Church until our modern age of skepticism and humanism. Believers, whether ancient or modern, know only the Gospel of the risen Savior.486
Leave A Comment